1. Mind reading
- Students will be able to carry out more trials for this task if they work in groups.
- Encourage students to design their own experiment and write down what they did.
2. Which rule wins?
- This is a challenging task and requires a good understanding of both theoretical probability and relative frequency.
- Students could work in groups to carry out this task.
- There are digital spinners available on line.
E.g. https://www.mathplayground.com/probability.html
Teaching ideas
This link displays a list of events.
Ask “For which of these could you calculate the probability?”
“For which of these would you need to collect some data or carry out some trials to be able to estimate the probability?”
“For those ones, how many trials or how much data do you think you would need to collect?”
This link displays the Getting started on page 341.
You could ask everyone in the class to draw a spiral and collect the results.
Discuss whether or not this would be sufficient trials to be able accurately to estimate the probability that if you asked someone
in the next classroom to draw a spiral it would be a clockwise spiral.
1. Put five coloured pencils (have two the same) into a hat or bag.
2. Get ten students to pull out a pencil without looking and then put it back. Have the other students record the colour each time.
3. After ten trials, ask the class to guess the colours of the five pencils.
Discuss how they made their prediction. Take the pencils out and show them. Students’ guesses will probably be wrong and
you can discuss why (too few trials).
4. Repeat with five different pencils, but this time do 50 trials.
5. Ask what you can say about the number of trials and the accuracy of the prediction.
Teacher notes
- Emphasise that the probability of some events cannot be calculated.
- For the practical on page 345 you could ask each group to do some trials and then combine the results.
- Students need to understand that if an experiment is repeated, the results will most likely be different.
- You could use the spinner at this website.
https://nrich.maths.org/6717
Teaching ideas
1. Tell students that you are going to choose a class messenger and class monitor for the day.
2. Ask ten volunteers each to put their name on a small piece of paper and give it to you.
3. Put all the names in a hat.
4. Ask “How many possible outcomes are there for either position?” (The answer is 10.) List the names on the board.
5. Draw one name out and announce that this person is class messenger.
6. Ask “How many possible outcomes are there now for class monitor ?” (The answer is 9.) List the names on the board.
7. Point out that this is one less possible outcome and that the outcomes for the class monitor are dependent on who was
chosen for class messenger.
8. Ask “Do you think these two events are dependent or independent?”
This link displays four pairs of events and asks students to say if each pair is dependent or independent.
Teacher notes
- Emphasise the difference between equally likely outcomes and those that are not equally likely.
- Emphasise the difference between events that are dependent and those that are independent, as this affects the number of
possible outcomes. - It is often necessary to ascertain all the possible outcomes using a table or diagram to make sure that all of the outcomes have
been counted.
Teaching ideas
This link displays some spinners coloured in different ways (not necessarily by sectors) and asks students about the probability of landing on colours.
Discuss the fact that it is the area that each colour covers that determines the probability.
This link displays cards for you to print, laminate and cut out. There are eight identical singers with microphones, five identical people playing keyboards, three identical people playing drums and nine identical people playing guitars.
1. Count the total number of cards and the number of each different type of picture card.
a Shuffle all the cards together and pick a card at random.
b What proportion of the cards are the same as the one you picked? What was the chance that you would pick this card?
(The chance of getting a card with a singer is 8/25, 32% or 0.32 because this is the proportion of cards that are singers,
with a keyboard player 5/25, 20% or 0.2 because this is the proportion of cards that have keyboard players, with a drum
player 3/25, 12% or 0.12 and with a guitar player 9/25, 36% or 0.36).
c Replace the card and repeat steps a and b several times.
2. Randomly remove five of the cards and count the total number of cards and the number of each different type of picture
card in the remaining cards.
a Repeat parts 1a and 1b several times.
3. How are the proportions of picking a particular type of card different in 1 and 2? Can you explain what has caused
the change?
4. If you randomly removed another 2 cards, describe how you would work out what the proportion might be.
5. How does using the proportion of a particular card as the chance of getting that card, if you picked a card at random,
relate to the following formula?
Probability of an event = number of ways of getting an event divided by the total number of outcomes.
- What if it doesn’t happen?
1. Write down on a piece of paper ten different sandwich fillings that you could get on a school camp.
(Examples, tomato, cheese, pickle…).
2. Put the pieces of paper into a hat.
3. Ask “What is the probability that I will draw out ‘tomato’ filling?" (1/10)
4. Ask “What is the probability that I will not draw out ‘tomato’ filling?” (9/10)
5. Ask ”What can you say about the probability that I will either draw out ‘tomato' filling or I won’t draw it out?”
(That is certain and has probability of 1.)
6. Ask “What does 1/10 + 9/10 equal?”
7. Ask “What is the probability of these?”
I won’t get a 6 when I roll a die
I won’t get a 3 or a 4 when I roll a die
"If I put your five names (name five students) into a hat, I won’t get ??? when I pull out one name."
1. Tell students you are going to toss a coin and roll a die.
2. Ask “What is the probability I will get a number less than 5 and a head?” Students are unlikely to be able to tell you.
3. Discuss how helpful it would be to list the outcomes on a table or diagram. Ask them to do this on mini whiteboards or
in their books.
4. Repeat question 2 and discuss the answer.
Teacher notes
- Students will usually give fractional answers to theoretical probability questions. Sometimes these need to be converted to percentages, decimals or ratios. You might need to revise with the students how to change fractions into percentages and thus
into decimals. - It is helpful for students to work with practical materials to assist them in understanding the probability formula,
Probability of an event = number of ways of getting the event divided by the total number of outcomes. - It is important that students understand that some events are impossible and have a probability of 0 and that some are certain and have a probability of 1. The probability scale helps with this understanding.
- Check that students understand why probability has to be between 0 and 1, with 0 being impossible and 1 being certain.
- Encourage students to think of probability as a proportion. For example, if there is a greater proportion of yellow counters in a bag then it is more likely that a yellow counter will be drawn out.
- Encourage understanding of the answer rather than routinely using a formula to calculate it.
- Emphasise that to calculate probability using the formula Probability of an event = number of ways of getting the event divided
by the total number of outcomes events must be equally likely to occur. For example, if there are two yellow beads, one red
bead and one green bead in a bag then it is not equally likely that you will get either yellow, green or red because there are more yellow beads than red or green. Although there are three colours the total number of outcomes is four because there are four
beads in the bag so the probablility of getting yellow is not 1/3. The probablilities of getting each colour are red 1/4, green 1/4
and yellow 2/4 or 1/2. - It is easier to see the outcomes which satisfy the event for which the probability is being calculated in a table or diagram.
Teaching ideas
1 Use a computer simulation to show that the greater the number of trials, the closer the relative frequency is to the
experimental probability.
a Spinner simulation
http://www.shodor.org/interactivate/activities/ExpProbability/
b Four simulations with dice, spinners etc
https://www.onlinemathlearning.com/math-games-collection.html
c Coin flip simulation
https://www.khanacademy.org/computer-programming/coin-flip-probability-simulator/1116198574
d This is a great set of interactive activities from Statistics NZ
https://www.stats.govt.nz/tools_and_services/schools_corner/activities/interactive-games.aspx
Teacher notes
- This site gives you a tutorial on how to use spreadsheets to make a simulation. In this case it is finding the total when two dice are rolled but you could adapt it for other situations.
https://screencast.com/t/ZmHuHRnv0T7d
Note: This link may only work on Apple products.
- Emphasise that the greater the number of trials, the closer the relative frequency will get to the theoretical probability, which
means that when you can only estimate a probability experimentally, a large number of trials needs to be carried out in order for
it to be accurate. - To save time, get groups to do the same experiment and combine the results.
- Emphasise that when an experiment is repeated, the results will not be exactly the same. This can be shown by looking at the results from different groups who carried out the same experiment.